http://dailynews.yahoo.com/h/nyt/20010801/bs/will_the_economy_ever_party_like_it_s_1999_don_t_count_on_it__1.html

Wednesday August 01 02:54 PM EDT 
Will the Economy Ever Party Like It's 1999? Don't Count on It.

By JONATHAN FUERBRINGER The New York Times

The release of revised data from the past few years has some economists arguing that the new economy was not as "new" as some had thought.

Two debates going on right now are how much more the economy will slow and what the state of growth and corporate earnings will be when the economy recovers.

The Bush Treasury, in a statement Tuesday to its Treasury Borrowing Advisory Committee, was relatively optimistic. But some other signals are not.

"Overall, while we cannot dismiss uncertainties about the progression of recovery in the business sector, it seems plausible that the worst of the slowdown may be behind us," the Treasury statement said. "The July Blue Chip private consensus forecast estimates real growth of 3 percent in the fourth quarter. At this point, there is little reason to believe that forecast would be far off the mark."

The statement also noted, however, the crushing impact on the economy this year of the sharp drop in corporate earnings. 

"The withering of capital investment reflects a combination of developments," the statement said. "Excess capacity, resulting in some cases from over-investment but in others from the current weakened demand, was one factor. In addition, a widespread profit squeeze caused not only investment plans to be slashed but also private payrolls to be cut by 350,000 workers during the second quarter."

Because corporate profit forecasts are still declining, the job-cutting and the decline in capital investment could continue and finally drag the economy into a formal recession. In the second quarter, when the economy all but halted with inflation-adjusted growth of just 0.7 percent at an annual rate, overall spending by businesses and consumers actually fell. It was only a spurt in state and local government spending that kept the economy above water.

According to First Call/Thomson Financial, the second-quarter profits of the companies in the Standard & Poor's 500-stock index are showing an overall decline of 17.3 percent. In the third quarter the projected decline is now 12.1 percent, way steeper than the 2.9 percent fall forecast in May. The fourth quarter is barely positive, with a projected 0.4 percent growth; in May analysts were forecasting a profit growth of 8.8 percent.

More negative news came Tuesday with the report that consumer confidence in July fell, rather then rising, as was the case for the regional manufacturing index of the National Association of Purchasing Management-Chicago.

And industrial commodity prices, which outside of oil normally receive little attention, are still weak, indicating that there is no near-term sign of a rebound in the United States and global economies. 

Because many economists and politicians are already looking to the recovery, the more interesting debate is how the economy will perform when it recovers. Will the "New Economy" return, with high productivity, stronger than average economic growth and sharp rises in corporate profits?

Some economists doubt that will happen and now argue that the new economy was not as "new" as some had thought. They note that the recent revisions in the historical data for the gross domestic product, which were released Friday, show that growth, worker productivity and corporate profits were not as strong as previously estimated.

The G.D.P. grew 2.8 percent, instead of 3.4 percent, from the fourth quarter of 1999 to the fourth quarter of last year. Growth in 1999 was also slower than previously reported. Corporate profit growth, as measured in the G.D.P., was also revised downward in 2000, rising 6.1 percent instead of 10.5 percent.

On productivity, Robert J. Barbera, chief economist at Hoenig & Company, did a rough calculation based on the lower growth rates and the assumption that the hours worked were the same.

In 1999 he estimates that productivity grew by 3.2 percent, instead of the previously reported 3.8 percent and that in 2000 productivity rose 2.7 percent, instead of 3.3 percent. For the first half of this year, he calculates that productivity is up 0.4 percent at an annualized rate.

For Mr. Barbera, this revision raises doubts about how strong productivity will be in the future. "You cannot go back to what wasn't there," he said.



Copyright ? 2001 Yahoo! Inc., and The New York Times Company. All rights reserved.
